College Football TimelineTHE COLLEGE FOOTBALL ARCHIVE
HomeRivalriesMuskingum vs Otterbein
College football / Rivalry archive

Muskingum vs Otterbein Timeline

Explore every documented meeting, final score and season in the recorded history between Muskingum and Otterbein.

PROGRAM ONEMuskingum4 recorded wins
HEAD TO HEAD4–0WINS · LOSSES
PROGRAM TWOOtterbein0 recorded wins
4Recorded meetings
2022Earliest documented
2025Most recent season
0Tied games
THE RIVALRY THROUGH TIME

Head-to-head timeline

Meetings are listed oldest first. Scores and dates reflect the available historical records.

4 games
  1. 2022
    Muskingum41 — 35Otterbein
    Oct 8, 2022Muskingum wonSherman Field at McConagha Stadium
  2. 2023
    Muskingum27 — 14Otterbein
    Sep 9, 2023Muskingum wonMemorial Stadium (Westerville, OH)
  3. 2024
    Muskingum24 — 7Otterbein
    Sep 14, 2024Muskingum wonSherman Field at McConagha Stadium
  4. 2025
    Muskingum37 — 13Otterbein
    Sep 27, 2025Muskingum wonMemorial Stadium (Westerville, OH)
THE COMPLETE SCOREBOOK

All recorded results

The latest documented meeting appears first.

SeasonMatchupScoreOutcome
2025Muskingum vs Otterbein37–13Muskingum won
2024Muskingum vs Otterbein24–7Muskingum won
2023Muskingum vs Otterbein27–14Muskingum won
2022Muskingum vs Otterbein41–35Muskingum won
OUR DATA STANDARD

Sources and historical coverage

These results are compiled from season-by-season records imported from CollegeFootballData. Only games with both final scores are counted. Older seasons and some lower-division records may be incomplete; the earliest documented year is not necessarily the first meeting ever played.

Page updated November 7, 2026 · Historical records are subject to correction.